Documenting unconventional love in the 21st century
- Text by Miss Rosen
In a culture where overexposure has become the new norm, intimacy and bonding is becoming increasingly complex. People adapt in any number of ways, adopting attitudes, behaviours, and even objects that allow them to channel the desire for love in a tangible way.
In the new exhibition Surrogate. A Love Ideal, opening February 21, American photographers Jamie Diamond and Elena Dorfman explore the expression of familial and romantic love between human and doll — an expression that elicits feelings of surprise, confusion, disgust, and even empathy from those who see it from the outside looking in.
“The dolls are so realistic when you see them, you inevitably have a visceral reaction whether you are repulsed or seduced,” says Diamond. Her series Forever Mothers (2012-2018) and Nine Months of Reborning (2014), portrays the lives of Reborners: a group of self-taught women artists who hand-make, collect, and engage with hyper-realistic baby dolls.
“Even extremely masculine men on the streets, the dolls would melt them,” she continues. “Their level of realism conjures up so much in you, triggering specific emotions relating to parenthood. Reborn dolls are used with Alzheimer patients as a form of therapy. It’s amazing: they release all these endorphins and oxytocin. They are memory triggers – and also comfort.”
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5153e/5153e3eeab17ccfcee25576743f4ac4994b9d6b7" alt=""
Elena Dorfman. CJ 3, 2002. From Still Lovers
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ed2d4/ed2d445c2ecee83c55266c8734ce6f9597ac002c" alt=""
Jamie Diamond. 7.11.11, 2012. From I promise to be a good mother
Once immersed, Diamond embraced the Reborner culture, becoming a maker herself. “I was a doll collector all throughout my childhood,” she says. “Ultimately, it’s about nurturing. It’s make-believe, fantasy, and role-play. None of the women I have met are crazy and think the dolls are real.”
Diamond notes that there is a lot of sensitivity and privacy given to the members of the community, which is something Dorfman echoes. In her series Still Lovers (2001-04), Dorfman documented the domestic lives of men and women who share their homes with sex dolls.
“The assumption in the world is that there must be something wrong with the people who own them,” the photographer says. “At that time nobody had seen this kind of life before. The people who owned dolls were terrified to let someone in their homes. There was a deep fear of the neighbours finding out because the response has been very violent and shameful.”
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4b812/4b8124a676c665b3a29058257e064dc6fc3a18a9" alt=""
Elena Dorfman. CJ & Taffy 5, 2002. From Still Lovers
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/07b05/07b05459f7dc8041912337328066afac2430989d" alt=""
Jamie Diamond. Mother Cherry, 2018. From I promise to be a good mother
“I hope that is shifting, as people are becoming more comfortable ways alternative ways of life, living, and loving other kinds of objects. It’s important to look at how the dolls are becoming, AI is literally upon us, and soon these dolls will be waking and talking. It’s not that far away.”
Both Diamond and Dorfman note that there is no prevailing archetype for adults who love dolls. Whatever their reason, they express love to an object that cannot judge them, and is fully receptive to the attention they are shown.
“I think we are uncomfortable with AI and robotics — it’s too real,” adds Diamond, when asked about the future. “We find it dystopian. People aren’t ready for this yet but in time they will be. This is only the beginning. “
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/36948/369487cc8eb3a5725f3d5cce81acb11d12868042" alt=""
Elena Dorfman. Ginger Brook 4, 2001. From the series, Still Lovers
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/502e7/502e7357439a6292970898b5952d12ae12031dc4" alt=""
Jamie Diamond. Mother Kyla, 2012. From Forever mothers
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bdeea/bdeea1ff7a5f99b8f2e691896bbe1c03802e1d01" alt=""
Elena Dorfman. Sidore 4, 2001. From the series Still Lovers
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/101d0/101d0e3b84c9e4c5a09d2379bcd0f7484e85098e" alt=""
Jamie Diamond. 4.12.12, 2012. From I promise to be a good mother
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3a6e0/3a6e0a23bf212ad4ef485a6eb86e569b75b346c4" alt=""
Elena Dorfman. Galatea 4, 2002. From the series Still Lovers
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/500c3/500c3171ba4bb64f1e0664242ae2780c4a334033" alt=""
Jamie Diamond. Mother Brenda, 2012. From Forever mothers
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5a8e9/5a8e994d8afd151abb8a4053350d9a64f6d05d28" alt=""
Elena Dorfman. Rebecca 1, 2001. From the series, Still Lovers
Surrogate. A Love Ideal is on view at Fondazione Prada in Milan through July 22, 2019.
Follow Miss Rosen on Twitter.
Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.
Latest on Huck
In the ’60s and ’70s, Greenwich Village was the musical heart of New York
Talkin’ Greenwich Village — Author David Browne’s new book takes readers into the neighbourhood’s creative heyday, where a generation of artists and poets including Bob Dylan, Billie Holliday and Dave Van Ronk cut their teeth.
Written by: Cyna Mirzai
How Labour Activism changed the landscape of post-war USA
American Job — A new exhibition revisits over 70 years of working class solidarity and struggle, its radical legacy, and the central role of photography throughout.
Written by: Miss Rosen
Analogue Appreciation: Emma-Jean Thackray
Weirdo — In an ever more digital, online world, we ask our favourite artists about their most cherished pieces of physical culture. Today, multi-instrumentalist and Brownswood affiliate Emma-Jean Thackray.
Written by: Emma-Jean Thackray
Meet the shop cats of Hong Kong’s Sheung Wan district
Feline good — Traditionally adopted to keep away rats from expensive produce, the feline guardians have become part of the central neighbourhood’s fabric. Erica’s online series captures the local celebrities.
Written by: Isaac Muk
How trans rights activism and sex workers’ solidarity emerged in the ’70s and ’80s
Shoulder to Shoulder — In this extract from writer Jake Hall’s new book, which deep dives into the history of queer activism and coalition, they explore how anti-TERF and anti-SWERF campaigning developed from the same cloth.
Written by: Jake Hall
A behind the scenes look at the atomic wedgie community
Stretched out — Benjamin Fredrickson’s new project and photobook ‘Wedgies’ queers a time-old bullying act by exploring its erotic, extreme potential.
Written by: Isaac Muk